A student with a shopping basket looking at items at a food pantry on a college campus.

Allison Shelley/Complete College Photo Library

In order to help the neediest students reach graduation and launch their careers, colleges should address basic needs insecurity with proactive, continuous support, rather than a triage approach, according to a new report from the nonprofit Complete College America.

Not all basic needs interventions are created equal, according to the report. On-campus food pantries can be helpful for students in a pinch, but meal scholarships or dining hall vouchers offer more stability in the long run. The same principle extends to housing support: Helping students access vouchers for low-income housing provides more security than connecting them to host homes or providing short-term options.

In the report, titled “Refocus Your College’s Basic Needs Support: A Guide to Directing Resources to Services That Improve Completion Rates,” the authors argue that strategic interventions will enable students to attend class, focus on their homework and ultimately earn a degree.

Yolanda Watson Spiva, president of Complete College America, said in a statement that addressing student basic needs is “the next frontier of the completion agenda.”

“Too often, what pulls students off course isn’t a math class. It’s losing a place to stay, an empty fridge, no ride to campus or child care that falls through,” Watson Spiva said in the statement. “Successfully addressing these needs ensures that students with increasingly diverse ages, work experiences and family responsibilities can find a path to and through college.”

To make the big-picture strategy shift, colleges don’t have to throw out all their existing interventions and start from scratch, said Meacie Fairfax, strategy director at Complete College America. Instead, they need to look at what they’re already offering, figure out whether students are aware of and using the existing services, and then improve data collection and coordination to monitor whether the services are actually helping them move toward graduation and career success. The report acts as a detailed guide for how to do that, she said.

“If you’re only giving support in the moment but it’s not long term, or if you’re not looking to see if that intervention has actually been successful, you may not actually be helping them,” Fairfax said. “You may be postponing what’s the next emergency, but you may not be helping them get to the finish line.”

The report notes, “Students’ healthy development is not separate from learning; it drives learning.”

Colleges should think about basic needs as falling into seven categories, the authors write: childcare and caregiving, financial stability, food, health care and mental health care, housing, technology access, and transportation.

Ranking interventions: Past research has shown high rates of basic needs insecurity across the undergraduate population, finding a greater likelihood of unmet basic needs among students from historically marginalized racial and ethnic groups, students who attend community colleges, and student parents, according to the Hope Center for Student Basic Needs. Unmet basic needs can contribute to mental health struggles and lower college completion rates.

The authors analyzed research on 21 different basic needs resources commonly supplied by colleges and ranked their effectiveness for students as strong, moderate or weak. Among the strongest interventions were free public transit, emergency grants, meal scholarships and basic needs centers that help students navigate what benefits are available to them. Interventions such as childcare subsidies and on-campus mental health counseling were found to be moderately effective, while other interventions were categorized as weak. The authors also looked at not-yet-studied interventions such as eviction-prevention programs and car purchase or repair subsidies.

“Even though colleges have made real progress, we know that there’s still a fundamental gap in that we don’t know if these services are actually helping students to stay enrolled and graduate,” Fairfax said.

In the report, Complete College America recommends that colleges create a “basic needs measurement system” to track structural barriers for students, as well as whether addressing those barriers affected their ability to pass their classes and continue in college. Fairfax said colleges already collect a lot of such data separately and creating the measurement system would just require a bit more coordination.

“When colleges track basic needs support data alongside completion metrics, basic needs support becomes part of institutional performance conversations,” the authors note in the report. “Leaders who previously viewed basic needs as tangential are likely to see evidence that capacity gaps or low usage rates are undermining retention.”

Get more content like this directly to your inbox. Subscribe here.

Next Story

More from The College Experience