MicroStockHub/iStock/Getty Images Plus
As a graduate program director and chair of the admissions committee for the last six years, I have reviewed hundreds of Ph.D. applications. During that time, I’ve noticed several common mistakes that can weaken a candidate’s chances for serious consideration. This advice is for anyone applying to Ph.D. programs who wants to submit the strongest possible application and maximize their chance of admission to the program of their dreams.
Do read the program’s website thoroughly. Most questions about application procedures and requirements can be answered there.
Don’t contact the program to ask questions that can be easily answered by looking online. Sending an email simply for the sake of having any contact with a program administrator does not impress. In fact, it can have the opposite effect.
Do give yourself plenty of time to assemble your application materials. Applications typically include several components (e.g., GRE or language test scores, reference letters, statement of purpose, transcripts). The logistics of requesting and assembling these pieces can take longer than you expect. Your statement of purpose deserves serious reflection and several drafts to perfect it.
Don’t wait until the last minute to request letters of recommendation. Professors are busy and need time to write strong letters. Give them at least a month.
Do pay close attention to each program’s specific instructions. Even if applications look similar, small differences matter. An incomplete application may not be reviewed at all, so it’s important to take note of the details.
Don’t submit your application after the deadline. Unless the program explicitly states that it accepts late or rolling applications, submissions received after the deadline are rarely considered.
Do ensure you meet the program’s minimum requirements for admission. The point of these requirements is to set you up for success.
Don’t take a chance and apply if you don’t meet the minimum requirements. Applications take time and cost money. Don’t waste both by hoping that an admissions committee will make an exception for you.
Do research how your interests align with a program. Look into its areas of strength, ongoing research projects and especially faculty interests.
Don’t email the program director to ask if you are a good fit. Program directors don’t know you, and it’s difficult to make that call based on a CV and introductory email. It’s your responsibility to determine if the program aligns with your goals.
Do consider a program holistically. What are the program’s specialties? Do they resonate with you? Are there multiple faculty members you would be excited to work with?
Don’t apply solely to work with one person. Faculty members change institutions, often unexpectedly. Sometimes they change their research focus. Or you may not vibe with that person in the way that you hoped. Plus, you will need a full committee to support your dissertation—not just one individual.
Do choose referees who can speak to your academic skills. Ideally, these are professors who have supervised or evaluated your work. They should have deep familiarity with your research, analysis and writing abilities.
Don’t ask an employer for a recommendation letter, unless they have firsthand knowledge about your research skills and experiences. It is normal to take a gap year, or maybe several, before starting a Ph.D. Your current employer may be tangentially related, or even unrelated, to your future goals. A glowing letter about your work ethic or teamwork is nice, but admissions committees need to know about your academic potential.
Do follow word-count guidelines for your statement of purpose. If none are given, keep it within two to three pages. Be concise and clear. Do not use jargon.
Don’t submit a statement of purpose without carefully proofreading it, especially if you recycle the same statement for multiple programs. Using the wrong university name signals carelessness. Basic grammar and punctuation mistakes are sloppy.
Do focus your statement of purpose on your preparation for the rigors of a graduate program, along with your research interests and future goals. Admissions committees look for candidates with demonstrated qualifications and experiences that suggest they will thrive in a Ph.D. program. Committees also want to see that you can form a research question and that your general interests align with available faculty support. (But don’t worry—you are not locked into the research ideas that you set out in this statement.)
Don’t forget to explain why you want to join that particular program. Show that you’ve done your homework on the department and its faculty. (Again, this is especially important if you reuse your statement for several schools.)
Do check your email regularly after the application deadline. Admissions committees may request additional information or invite you for a Zoom interview. A prompt response is a good indication of your genuine interest in that program.
Don’t contact program staff to ask about the status of your application. As difficult as it may be to wait, programs receive many applications. They will notify you with their decision as soon as possible.
Taking time to prepare your application thoughtfully shows that you understand the seriousness of this next step in your educational career. The best applications come from candidates who approach the process with intention: researching programs carefully, tailoring their materials and presenting themselves honestly. Remember, this is not just about being admitted—it’s about finding the right intellectual home for you.
