In this episode of The Key, Inside Higher Ed’s news and analysis podcast, IHE’s student success reporter, Joshua Bay, joins Editor in Chief Sara Custer. They discuss the trends in student success that have caught Joshua’s eye, including libraries and AI literacy, workforce readiness, and tackling loneliness. He shares case studies from programs that are making a difference for students in and outside the classroom. He also gives a sneak peek into his new project.

Thanks to our partners at Strada for sponsoring this episode.

Strada Educatrion Foundation logo

 

Follow us on Apple Podcasts Spotify

 

View Transcript

Note: Transcripts may be created with the help of automated tools and lightly edited for clarity.

Transcript

Sara Custer: Hello and welcome to The Key, Inside Higher Ed’s news and analysis podcast. I’m Sara Custer, editor in chief at Inside Higher Ed, and joining me today is our student success reporter, Joshua Bay. He’s been on the beat for three months and he’s here to discuss the trends in student success that have caught his eye. He’s got some very helpful case studies from programs that are making a difference for students in and outside of the classroom. He also shares his experiences of speaking with the educators dedicated to this work. And he gives us a sneak peek into his new project. Thank you to our partners at Strada for sponsoring this episode. Enjoy! This episode is sponsored by Strada Education Foundation. At Strada, they’re focused on one goal: helping clear the path between education and opportunity, especially for those with the most standing in their way. Learn more at strada.org. Joshua Bay, welcome to The Key.

Joshua Bay: Oh my goodness, Sara Custer. Hi.

Sara Custer: I’m very loving this enthusiasm. Yeah, straight out of the gate. I love it.

Joshua Bay: Straight out of the gate. Oh, yeah.

Sara Custer: So, Joshua, for our eagle-eared, if that’s a term, listeners, you were on the Voices of Student Success podcast at the end of last year when you first joined Inside Higher Ed as our student success reporter. We’ve brought you back on now that you’ve been in the role for a little over three months because I want to hear how it’s going for you and what sort of trends you’re picking up on in your student success beat. And then we also have a special announcement at the end of the episode, but we’ll get to that in a minute. Of course, though, to begin, because we are on The Key, we have to start with our segment: Where are my keys?

Sound clip: Dude, where are my keys?

Sara Custer: So, Joshua, I would love to hear your story about when you lost your keys or someone else’s keys or something and the hilarity that ensued.

Joshua Bay: Oh, my goodness. So, the story that I have for everyone: I was 19 years old. It was my very first internship. My boss was quite the character. So, he comes into the room and he goes, Oh my goodness. He comes into the office. He’s like, Oh, my goodness gracious. I got into a car accident. And everyone’s like, Oh my God, are you okay? Like, what happened? And then he goes on this like tirade about how he hit a parked car, pretty much. I mean, it was a very, it was a very minor car accident. So, yeah, so he was very upset by it because he had just gotten that car, he got into Tesla. Um, and it was during the time when like Teslas were like really new. Um, and I think that they only like they had only rolled out like so many of those cars. So, um, but because he got into that little minor car accident, he was very upset. And because I was like the intern, he pretty much just like threw it on me. He was like, Joshua, I drop everything you’re doing. I need you to figure out like how to fix my car. And like, I need you to take, I need you to take it, take it to the repair shop, get it repaired. And I need you to get, um, I also need you to get me a rental car. So he pretty much like gave me his keys and was like, figure it out. But mind you, I’m 19 years old. Like, I’ve never rented a car before. Like, I think I had just started driving like that year. Oh, my God. I really didn’t know what to do. I was like, oh, okay.

Sara Custer: Okay. Just throwing you into the deep end, kid. Figure it out.

Joshua Bay: Yeah. He just threw me into the deep end and was like, figure it out. And he pretty much gave me, he pretty much told me, like, okay, you have till the end of the day to figure it out. And I was like, okay. I had like other classwork I had to figure out, but I was like, you know what? It’s fine. This is fine. So yeah, so he gave me his keys and getting his car repaired was pretty. That one was actually a lot easier than I had anticipated. But it was getting him this rental car, which was the bane of my existence. And I found this really nice BMW. I get it for him. But before I press charge and get things moving, I go to his office and I tell him, Hey, like before I get you this rental car, like, how does this look? Is everything good before I like charge it on your credit card? And then he goes, No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. I cannot drive that car. I only drive Teslas. And I was like, okay. So I go back and I’m like going through like any kind of like car rental like agency I could find to look for like a rental Tesla. But because Teslas were so new at the time, there weren’t any rental Teslas. You could only just like buy them. So then I pretty much go back to his office and I tell him like, so I can’t find you a rental Tesla. And he was extremely upset. He was like, you need to figure it out by the end of the day. You have my keys. You have my credit card. Figure it out. And I was like, okay, like crashing out in my desk. But yeah, but I pretty much just like found this person online. I was like digging deep into the internet. Really like my predicated journalism skills were coming into work. Yeah. I found this woman who was willing to lend me her Tesla. And I was like, okay.

Sara Custer: Her personal Tesla.

Joshua Bay: Her personal Tesla. She was willing to lend me. She was willing to lend me her personal Tesla. And then she drives down from Arizona that day. And yeah, and it took her a while to get here. So then I pretty much like waited at his house. And this person finally came in with her Tesla. She gave me like, she gave me the, you know, she gave me the car. I cleaned up the car. I put like a little bow on it that I found at the Dollar Tree. I was like, I don’t know. I was like, I wanted to be nice. And I gave and I, you know, I left the Tesla there. And then, yeah. So then, and then I drive back home, wake up the next morning, my phone’s blowing up. And it’s pretty much my boss saying, I see the Tesla, but I can’t get inside. And I was like, what do you mean you can’t get inside? I left the keys in your house. Turns out I lost the keys. And this whole, because I was like, I lost the keys to the new Tesla.

Sara Custer: The rental Tesla.

Joshua Bay: The rental Tesla. And I was just like searching for it everywhere I could find, like inside my own car. Like maybe I like took it with me like when I went home. Like maybe I dropped it somewhere like outside of his house. I was trying to figure out like where this Tesla was or like where the keys for this Tesla was. Turns out I left it inside the cupboard of the Tesla.

Sara Custer: Okay. Yeah. Like the glove box.

Joshua Bay: The glove box of the Tesla, but I didn’t realize that for the longest time. But then I spent the next day just like scouring like the gutters of Los Angeles trying to figure out where this, where this key was.

Sara Custer: A lot of questions. So you eventually remembered or did you think to like, oh, maybe I put them in the car. Let me just check all the nooks and crannies in the car for the keys.

Joshua Bay: You know, it was so funny. Actually, I don’t know if this is funny. This might just, well, we’ll see. The only reason why I figured it out that it was in the glove compartment was not because like I was the one that found it, because my boss like stopped calling me out of nowhere. So I spent like a good like half day like still looking for the keys. And then finally I show up to the office with like my tail between my legs, about to tell him like, I’m so sorry. But then he showed up to the office and he was like, what are you doing? Like, why are you late for work? And I was like, I don’t, I don’t know what you mean. He’s like, I found the keys. Or he was like, the keys were in the glove compartment. So he didn’t tell me that he found them the entire day. Meanwhile, I was like searching for it. I was like, oh, here we are.

Sara Custer: Oh. Oh, here we are. Oh, I feel so bad for 19-year-old intern, Joshua. For that, 19-year-old intern.

Joshua Bay: Yeah. I was like, okay.

Sara Custer: Many skills that I’ve seen exhibited in this story, resiliency, resilience, determination. Finding problem solving, critical thinking. I mean, these are all, maybe you should put this story on your resume. Not now because you’re not looking for a job, obviously. But listen, well, thank you so much for sharing that story, Joshua, in our segment, Where are my keys?

Sound clip: Oh, man, have you seen my keys?

Sara Custer: So let’s move on to the real reason why you are on The Key, Joshua, which is to tell us about the trends that you’re seeing as you’ve been covering this beat for us. I’m going to ask you for two or three to share with us. So I’ll hand it over to you. What’s really stood out to you on the student success beat so far?

Joshua Bay: Yeah, I mean, there’s quite a number of things that have stood out in the student success beat. I find myself very intrigued by a lot of like the mental health initiatives that are happening on different college campuses and also the different like ways and different metrics that college leaders are using to measure whether their programs or their initiatives are effective for students. I think student belonging and student loneliness are different metrics that are being used among higher ed leaders, particularly their student success professionals. I found myself very intrigued by student loneliness. I’ve definitely done a lot of research and a lot of coverage, like Trellis Strategies had some really good pieces. The Jed Foundation also has some really good research in regards to student loneliness. So that’s something that I find myself really digging into when it comes to the student success beat. I think workforce readiness is also something that’s being talked about a lot in this space. And what that, you know, what that looks like. I hate to be so reductive by using the word ROI because I think there’s so much more that can be talked about in this space than just saying the return on investment of a degree. But ultimately, are students getting the kind of career or getting the kind of income or whatever their goal is? Are they getting what they were looking to get from their college degree, especially when it comes to student loans, when it comes to that financial investment? Is it equating to the type of career that they are intending to gain? I was like reading this one like LinkedIn post that pretty much said that a lot of the new research that gets put out when it comes to workforce readiness always focuses on the financial aspects of what that return on investment looks like for a college student. But there are so many other careers that maybe don’t necessarily equate to a really high financial outcome, but students will actively choose those careers, whether it’s like social work, I think teaching falls into this, maybe journalism in some extent. And oftentimes students understand that financial, like financial outcomes of certain careers aren’t going to equate to someone in like in tech or someone who worked in finance, but they actively choose that. So it’s like, how do how when we think about career readiness and that return on investment on the college degree, are finances the only, are they the only metric we should be using or are they just like a piece of the pie?

Sara Custer: Well, I was just going to say, I mean, the ROI, I mean, that is, and that’s a conversation that’s been going on in higher ed for a number of years. How are we measuring the effectiveness of degrees? ROI is just one measurement. It’s not all of them, but it’s certainly one of the easiest ones to measure, which I think is why a lot of people fall back on it. Increased tuition prices is also another reason to look at ROI because students are investing so much in this education. What are they actually getting back from that? And for a long time, higher ed has talked about this degree premium that you get whenever you have a bachelor’s degree, which the research bears that out. That’s certainly the case. But I think sometimes when we’re having these conversations and we’re talking about the degree premium, it’s inevitable that we’re going to go back to return on investment and that going into graduate earnings, which I agree is often a blunt tool and a little bit unfair whenever we’re thinking about these careers that are so important to society, like teaching, like social work, like some of the humanities majors and degrees. So we need artists in the world, even if they’re, you know, they’re not making the big bucks like some of the other sectors. So I’m glad to hear that you’re picking up on that and you’re exploring that tension there between ROI and workforce readiness and then what students are wanting to get from their degree beyond just earnings when they graduate.

Joshua Bay: Yeah. I think that tension has definitely been something that I both like find myself seeing when I have these conversations with different higher ed folks, but then also as I’m seeing that, I find myself now explicitly asking during interviews because I’ve definitely heard pushback from faculty when it comes to university leaders explicitly saying workforce readiness or some career preparation or something in that regard, like including that in their mission or including that into some kind of larger campus-wide initiative. And, you know, I think more recently, I’ve been asking a lot of higher ed folks whenever I’m doing a piece like this, like, what do you say to critics who say that workforce readiness or explicitly having these campus-wide initiatives with workforce readiness? What would you say to folks who think it’s kind of like a blow or that it’s a and just goes against, you know, the liberal arts and what the liberal arts is supposed to be? And I tend to get a very similar response back, but just that, you know, workforce readiness is already is already ingrained in the liberal arts experience. It’s just now a matter of professors or faculty members or other admin explicitly saying that. And that’s kind of like the kind of tends to be like the response that I get.

Sara Custer: Yeah, I think that’s fair. Certainly. It’s not everybody’s interpretation of the liberal arts, but it’s so broad. And a lot of people I talk to say the same thing that this is the liberal arts in action is expanding to apply to everything, a broad spectrum of subjects and issues that students are studying. So what else? So we’ve talked about belonging and loneliness, workforce development, and tell me one more trend that you’ve been following.

Joshua Bay: Yeah, I think artificial intelligence and how colleges and institutions are really grappling with the rise of artificial intelligence. You know, we’re seeing some institutions have like really large like campus-wide initiatives. Like I know DeVry University is including AI and AI tools and AI literacy across all of the courses that they’re offering at their university. You’re also seeing how campus libraries and librarians are finding themselves in this space and how they’ve always been leaders when it comes to information and data literacy and AI literacy is an extra piece to a lot of the work that librarians on college campuses have already been doing for students and for faculty, et cetera. I’m seeing AI readiness being integrated into first-year experiences at different institutions. How AI literacy falls into workforce readiness is, I might be seeing that being a big conversation when it comes to that first-year experience to really kind of like ground the conversations as students matriculate that this is what we value. Or even just as simple as like courses or micro-credentials I’ve been seeing that include AI literacy. So I’m kind of like seeing it in many different capacities, though, of course, like AI is a very largely uncharted territory. So it is quite interesting to me to see how institutions are responding to it. Sure, like students and faculty also have their pushback when it comes to integrating AI and AI tools. So it’s definitely a really interesting conversation to find myself in.

Sara Custer: And I think one thing that is great about our student success pieces and the ones that you’ve been writing is they really bring real world examples to the themes that you’re talking about. So let’s go into that a little bit. So you talked about AI and libraries. Give us some ideas or some of the case studies that you’ve reported on of what some libraries at different institutions are doing.

Joshua Bay: Yeah, I did a piece from Bryn Mawr College and had the chance to chat with the librarian who was super lovely and very insightful. And she described campus libraries as like AI sandboxes, which I thought was a really like intriguing way of describing it. And for her, like AI sandboxes were pretty much just shared spaces for experimentation and ethical use of AI for students and for faculty to just, you know, almost like neutral spaces where they can ask those questions. It’s really interesting to see like librarians in this space and like how they’ve led like workshops or different seminars or they are like guest speakers in different courses. I think some questions that they find themselves asking students is, you know, how exactly are you using AI? Like, are you using it to ideate like essay ideas or to start research or stuff like that? And instead of coming into it with judgment that they’re using AI in this kind of regard, they pretty much come in with like action plans of like, oh, okay, so you’re using it for, I don’t know, like kind of going back to what I was saying earlier, like we’re using it to ideate different essay topics. Maybe we shouldn’t use this, we shouldn’t use this platform, but maybe you should try this platform, or maybe we should be asking this kind of question, or we should be prompting these AI chatbots in this way, kind of like getting students and getting faculty members to really critically think about not whether or not AI is being used in like an academic setting, but like how it’s being used, what kind of questions we’re asking, how we’re prompting AI so it kind of serves the purpose without kind of removing critical thinking from this equation. So I find that that was a really interesting way that I’ve seen AI being used and different actors within this, within a college space.

Sara Custer: Yeah, I love that. Libraries getting involved in that, that is totally their role on campus and has historically been that for so long, is that information literacy role. And this is just kind of an evolution of that. So I’m kind of working backwards here on the trends that you were telling us about. Give us a good example of some workforce readiness programs that you’ve covered.

Joshua Bay: Oh, there’s like so many different workforce readiness programs. I feel like I really like dig my like teeth into it because I get really intrigued by, I think I get particularly intrigued by like what happens in like community colleges because I feel like community colleges and the amazing work that they do doesn’t get covered enough. So I find myself really like wanting to look for those programs, look for those initiatives. I think one example that comes to mind was in Los Angeles. There’s four community colleges there that I think every, I believe every quarter, they actively meet up. I think their student success and like their career advisors, like they actively meet up and they share ideas and they share examples about how they approach different like organizations or just like different companies that their students find themselves wanting to apply for internships or wanting to apply for other work-based learning, you know, work-based learning opportunities. And they pretty much share like different ways that they approach that for their students. And they also figure out ways in which maybe they’re all approaching the same company. So how can they just approach that company together so that company doesn’t have to have the same conversation like over and over again? And instead, like there’s just like a group of institutions that are coming to them together.

Sara Custer: So that’s really smart. So I think it’s a consortium for workforce.

Joshua Bay: Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. It’s like they’re finding ways to just collaborate in very effective ways for their students and just ensure that, like, you know, there’s no competition here. We just want to, we just want what’s best for our students. Yeah. So I think.

Sara Custer: So which institutions was that?

Joshua Bay: Yeah. So it’s West LA College, Compton College, El Camino College and Los Angeles Southwest College. Yeah. So they pretty much created this like regional cross-sector strategy just to make sure that they’re expanding opportunities for all students in their institutions to get the paid internships, the work-based learning opportunities that they’re intending for their students.

Sara Custer: Yeah. That’s great. That’s one example. Yeah, one example that I wanted to call out from your work is work that Meharry Medical College is doing. It’s an HBCU in Tennessee. Tell us about that one.

Joshua Bay: Oh my goodness. Meharry Medical College, that was, it was such a labor of love to just write that story because I had the chance to chat with, she was a fourth-year dental student, Kyla Marks. I also had the chance to chat with the, she was the dean of the school. Her name is Julie Gray. So Kyla and Julie, and they just shared with me just some of the really amazing work that they’re doing to really fill in those healthcare gaps in rural communities in Tennessee. I started it out with the story of Kyla Marks’ grandmother. And she pretty much told the story about how her grandmother, she grew up in this like really small, like rural town in Mississippi where there was not a lot of access to dental care. And by the time that her grandmother was like in her mid-30s, she had like lost like all of her teeth, pretty much. So she described the experience of coming into the world, like being born into the world, and noticing even at a young age that her grandmother never really smiled around her. Not necessarily because her grandmother wasn’t like a happy person, but because she had felt that insecurity about her smile and you know, having lost like many teeth throughout her life. And she, you know, when her grandmother had passed away, she kind of made it her mission to really pursue not just like dentistry, but pursue dentistry in these rural communities where, you know, maybe there’s, you know, healthcare gaps or maybe there’s just, you know, different conversations happening when it comes to accessing health care and dental care and just making sure that you know good information is being put into those communities. So I feel very grateful that she had said that because I think it really just added a lot of color to the story and added a lot of just more of like the why about why, not just Kyla, but like why a lot of the students at Meharry Medical School do what they do. Because I was bringing like other examples more broadly about how they visit youth in state custody. They travel directly to the state supported facilities just to ensure that vulnerable children don’t fall through the cracks and they get the kind of health care that they need. And when I talked to the dean of the school, Julie, she had pretty much talked to me about how important mobility is for a lot of, you know, for a lot of folks in rural communities, particularly for youth in state custody, because maybe they’re shackled or maybe they have transportation issues. So, you know, the school and the dental students in that school taking that extra step to ensure that they’re giving, you know, the care that they need and they’re also, you know, doing, you know, they’re having those like really nice conversations because you don’t really know fully what the story is of a young person and why they found themselves in those facilities. Yeah. So, yeah, I mean, it was just a really nice, it was a really nice conversation.

Sara Custer: You gave really great quotes, I will say. Yeah, and I just, and I love the workforce readiness element of it as well, which and you brought in the real human side of that and how much the deans and the professors in the Meharry Medical School are showing that empathy and teaching that empathy or making sure that students bring that to their work. And even on that story, we can, you’ve got an image of this semi-truck with a trailer, this mobile dental trailer that they take to different areas in rural Tennessee to make sure that they are expanding access to dental care. And then also it’s a great opportunity for those students to have experience working on patients. So it’s a great story of kind of merging two needs for those communities.

Joshua Bay: Yeah. There’s this like, there’s this quote that Julie had said to me that really captures the story as a whole. She said, she always tells her students, you have a responsibility to give your time, your talents and your treasures to the folks that you serve. How you do that is up to you, but it’s a responsibility as a dentist to give back in the way that was given to you. And I think that really just like, I don’t know, like it captures just, you know, how much like workforce readiness is not just, you know, preparing you for a job, but also understanding the why about why you’re doing that, that, that career, why you’re pursuing this career. So, so yeah, it was a very nice quote. Yeah, it was a very nice quote that I still stick in my head to even understand my, even my own why about why I’m here, why I’m a journalist, why I’m, um, why I find myself really enjoying the student success pieces.

Sara Custer: Yeah. Well, just to wrap up in the time that we’ve got left, I mentioned at the top that you, we had an announcement and you will be joining the airwaves of The Key podcast, the Inside Higher Ed airwaves. We are bringing back Voices of Student Success. And do you want to tell us what your plan is with the podcast?

Joshua Bay: Yeah, we’ll be relaunching Voices of Student Success. We’ll really just be exploring what really shapes students’ experiences on college spaces. So, you know, as me and Sara have been chatting throughout, you know, throughout this episode, right, like a lot of my coverage is focused on student mental health, workforce readiness, AI. And, you know, the Voices of Student Success series will really be bringing in those stories, that research, those perspectives. Yeah, to really help educators, policymakers, higher ed leaders just really understand the challenges, but also opportunities that define student success today. So, yeah, should I give them like a little preview about what?

Sara Custer: Yes.

Joshua Bay: Here’s a preview.

Sara Custer: What’s, yeah, what’s the first series?

Joshua Bay: Yeah, so I’ll be doing like a bunch of different four-episode series. But the first one, right, the first theme will be all about student mental health, right? So I’ll dive into the state of student well-being, loneliness, belonging, what does supporting first-generation, marginalized and LGBTQ students look like, especially right now at a time when DEI is under attack. We’ll be talking about institutional responsibility. So what does that look like in this space? And then also, you know, how has AI shaped or reshaped, I guess, student support on campus? So those will be, that’s kind of like a little taste of some of the questions that we’ll be thinking about and we’ll be exploring for this first series. But yeah, I think everyone just has to stay tuned and see what we have in store.

Sara Custer: And when is the first episode airing?

Joshua Bay: So the first episode is airing. It’s like drum roll, please. Should we play like a little like drum roll? It’ll be airing on Thursday, April 23. So, yeah, I mean, mark it and look out for it. Like, we’ll put the notification off. First episode.

Sara Custer: Yes. First episode of Joshua Bay on Voices of Student Success talking about mental health support on campus for students, April 23rd. Joshua, this has been an absolute pleasure. Thank you so much for joining us, for sharing some of the trends that you’ve been watching as a journalist covering the beat of student success for Inside Higher Ed and for sharing the story of the Tesla story of Joshua as an intern. Well, I appreciate you sharing it. Thanks so much, Joshua, and we’ll see you soon.

Joshua Bay: Thank you. Thanks, Sara.

Sara Custer: This episode is sponsored by Strada Education Foundation. At Strada, they’re focused on one goal: helping clear the path between education and opportunity, especially for those with the most standing in their way. Learn more at strada.org.

Share This Article