Skip to main content

Search
Subscribe

Menu

Search
Subscribe
Insider Dashboard
My Account
- Menu
- Subscribe
- Find a Job
- Hubs
- Student Success
  
  Student Voice
  
  Academic Life
  
  Health & Wellness
  
  The College Experience
  
  Life After College
- Special
- Podcasts
  
  The Key
  
  Academic Minute
  
  Campus
  
  The Pulse
  
  Weekly Wisdom
- Reports & Data
- Events
- Quick Takes
- Solutions
- Institutional Subscriptions
- Advertising & Marketing
- Consulting Services
- Data & Insights
- Hiring & Jobs
- Event Partnerships
- Campus+
- More
- Post a Job
- Campus
- About
- Contact Us

Opinion

Columns
The Education of Oronte Churm

June 02, 2008

The Recursive Self

Next Story

Opinion

Columns Debatable Ideas

The Shils Report and Academic Merit

It’s not a triumphant monument to academic merit, but an attack that seeks to purge leftist faculty.

Written By

Share This Article

Campus
Resources for faculty and staff.

Strong labs are built on shared ownership – with students as collaborators
The power of feedback to build belonging in online learning
How to establish a culture of care on campus
Make your higher education meetings neurodivergent-friendly
Make learning fun with mini whiteboards

Don't miss a single story

Subscribe for unlimited access to news and opinion.

Subscribe for $119/year

Company

Contact Us
About Us
Work with Us
History
Meet the Team

Advertise
Subscriptions
Find a Job
Post a Job

Legal

Rights & Permissions
Privacy
Terms of Service
Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

Newsletter

Create a free account and get higher ed's most essential news, analysis, and career advice delivered to your inbox.

Copyright © 2026 Inside Higher Ed All rights reserved.

Menu
Insider Dashboard
My Account
Subscribe
Find a Job
News
Faculty
- Contingent Faculty
- Curriculum
- Teaching
- Learning & Assessment
- Diversity & Equity
- Career Development
- Tenure
- Retirement
- Labor & Unionization
- Shared Governance
- Academic Freedom
- Research
- Books & Publishing
Students
- Academics
- Graduate students and Postdocs
- Retention
- Financial Aid
- Careers
- Residential Life
- Athletics
- Free Speech
- Physical & Mental Health
- Safety
Diversity
- Race & Ethnicity
- Sex & Gender
- Socioeconomics
- Religion
- Disability
- Age
Admissions
- Traditional-Age
- Adult & Post-Traditional
- Transfer
- Graduate
Tech & Innovation
- Teaching & Learning
- Artificial Intelligence
- Digital Publishing
- Data Analytics
- Libraries
- Administrative Tech
- Alternative Credentials
Business
- Financial Health
- Cost-Cutting
- Revenue Strategies
- Academic Programs
- Physical Campuses
- Mergers & Collaboration
- Fundraising
Institutions
- Research Universities
- Regional Public Universities
- Community Colleges
- Private Nonprofit Colleges
- Minority-Serving Institutions
- Religious Colleges
- Women's Colleges
- Specialized Colleges
- For-Profit Colleges
Governance
- Executive Leadership
- Trustees & Regents
- State Oversight
- Accreditation
Government
- Politics & Elections
- Courts
- Student Aid Policy
- Science & Research Policy
- State Policy
- Colleges & Localities
Workplace
- Employee Satisfaction
- Remote & Flexible Work
- Staff Issues
Global
- Study Abroad
- International Students in U.S.
- U.S. Colleges in the World
Opinion
- Opinion
Views
- Intellectual Affairs
Career Advice
- Seeking a Faculty Job
- Advancing in the Faculty
- Teaching
- Seeking an Administrative Job
- Advancing as an Administrator
- Diversity
Columns
- The Academic Worker
- Beyond Transfer
- Call to Action
- Confessions of a Community College Dean
- Debatable Ideas
- Echoes in the Quad
- Editor’s Note
- Everything Is Fine
- Just Visiting
- Leadership in Higher Education
- Learning Innovation
- Online: Trending Now
- The Public Scholar
- Resident Scholar
- Small World
- Tough Love
Letters
Hubs
Student Success
- Student Voice
- Academic Life
- Health & Wellness
- The College Experience
- Life After College
Special
Podcasts
- The Key
- Academic Minute
- Campus
- The Pulse
- Weekly Wisdom
Reports & Data
Events
Quick Takes
Solutions
Institutional Subscriptions
Advertising & Marketing
Consulting Services
Data & Insights
Hiring & Jobs
Event Partnerships
Campus+
More
Post a Job
Campus
About
Contact Us