In which a veteran of cultural studies seminars in the 1990s moves into academic administration and finds himself a married suburban father of two. Foucault, plus lawn care.
Horrifying story of the College of New Rochelle, leadership by asking questions, summer Pell and more.
The story of the College of New Rochelle is horrifying. Apparently -- and I have no knowledge beyond the press account -- the college skipped payroll tax payments for a couple of years. Now that those have come to light, the college is in dire straits. Even with a huge anonymous donation to deflect the wolf from the door, it’s still engaging in cascading cuts, with planned layoffs of tenured faculty as the next step.
The tax evasion aspect is unusual, but the larger contours of the story aren’t. Going broke happens slowly, until it happens quickly. By the time there’s widespread awareness, it’s usually too late.
Assuming the story is true, I have a hard time imagining how auditors could have missed something so large and basic for years. At best, it would require a series of catastrophic system failures. I’m guessing there was a conscious effort to hide it from the auditors.
The story suggests that there’s still hope for the college, even though its next step is layoffs of tenured faculty (!). Here’s hoping it’s able to survive, and that the layoffs aren’t as bad as they could be.
Someone I trust told me once that my leadership style involves a lot of leading with questions. I do a lot of “what if” and “why,” as opposed to declaring. She was right.
I was reminded of that in reading this interview with Valerie Smith, the president of Swarthmore. It’s always nice to see very successful people using an approach you recognize.
Leading with questions -- as opposed to “leading questions,” which is a form of manipulation -- requires establishing a context in which it’s okay to be wrong. It’s hard to create a new reality all at once; progress is necessarily partial and halting, with a stream of course corrections along the way. It requires the audacity to declare “it doesn’t have to be this way,” along with the humility to admit “I hadn’t thought of that.” My best staff meetings resemble writing workshops, in which everyone has license to bat ideas around, and the lowest-ranking person can contradict the highest-ranking one without fear.
It only works when everyone is operating in good faith. But when they are, the ideas that come out tend to benefit from having had more eyes on them.
The biggest cost I’ve found is that some people expect Leadership (capital “L”) to involve lots of pounding on tables, loud declarations, and visible assertions of alpha status. Done differently, they don’t recognize it. If your image of the Leader involves lots of scenery-chewing, the questioning style can look aloof or passive. Over time, results speak for themselves, but that presumes the presence of time.
Rumor has it that summer Pell may have bipartisan support. Let me add my voice to the chorus. If we want to encourage students to finish, we need to enable them to attend year-round. Forcing interruptions causes unnecessary delay. The Pell fund has the money to cover summers. Here’s hoping Congress does the right thing.
Carrying on in the family tradition, The Boy is a big Michigan fan, so I took him to the Michigan-Rutgers basketball game on Wednesday. It was great fun, and some good father-son bonding time. But it was a little unnerving to see the Busch campus after all these years.
I went to grad school at Rutgers in the 90’s, when the Busch campus was pretty undeveloped. Now it’s almost entirely new, along with the access roads leading to it. (That’s a good thing; the traffic on the old Metlars Lane used to be horrific.) Even New Brunswick looks a lot spiffier than it did when I lived there.
It was sort of shocking to see the money that had been spent there. Coming from a community college stuck in an austerity trap, the resources on display at what is still a state school were hard to believe. I don’t begrudge them that, but I wouldn’t mind seeing at least some of that wealth shared…
Read more by
You may also be interested in...
Inside Higher Ed’s Blog U
What Others Are Reading