A lawsuit against the American Studies Association argues its support for the academic boycott of Israel falls outside the scope of its mission.
Four professors on Wednesday sued the American Studies Association, alleging that its boycott of Israeli universities violates Washington, D.C., law governing nonprofit corporations. The suit alleges that the academic boycott of Israel falls outside the scope of the ASA’s corporate charter and stated mission to promote the study of American culture.
The suit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia against the ASA and six named current or former association leaders whom the plaintiffs accuse of “hijacking” the group to advance their own political views. In late 2013, the ASA’s National Council unanimously passed a resolution endorsing the academic boycott of Israel. The council subsequently presented the boycott resolution to the full membership for an online vote in what the association describes on its website as "an unprecedented action to ensure a democratic process." Of the 1,252 members who voted over a 10-day period, 66.05 percent were in favor of the boycott.
The lawsuit against ASA alleges that this vote did not conform with procedures outlined in the association's bylaws, and argues that for a membership vote on the boycott resolution to be valid it would have needed to take place on the first full day of the association's annual meeting (rather than electronically after the meeting had concluded) and would have required approval by a two-thirds majority of those present. (The 66.05 percent tally in favor of the boycott in the electronic vote fell just short of the two-thirds mark.)
More broadly, the suit argues that ASA’s constitution at the time of the vote limited the association’s activities to the “promotion of the study of American culture” and that the defendants’ “operation of the ASA as a ‘social justice organization,’ including through the promotion of a boycott against Israel, is outside and inconsistent with the purpose of the ASA’s constitution.” The lawsuit argues that this alleged ultra vires conduct -- that is, conduct outside the scope of the ASA's organizational authority -- has “frustrated the legitimate aims and purposes of the ASA” and “resulted in the improper expenditure of ASA funds related to membership dealings, public relations, legal matters and other items including employee time and effort.”
The lawsuit against the ASA comes as the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement against Israel has gained momentum in parts of American academe. The American Anthropological Association is currently voting on a proposed resolution to boycott Israeli academic institutions. Other smaller scholarly organizations that have since 2013 approved resolutions supporting the academic boycott of Israel include the African Literature Association, the Association for Asian American Studies, the Critical Ethnic Studies Association, the National Women’s Studies Association and the Native American and Indigenous Studies Association.
The American Association of University Professors opposes boycotts as “inimical” to principles of academic freedom. Other BDS opponents reject what they see as a singling out of the Jewish state of Israel for special opprobrium.
“This is not just about the American Studies Association,” said Kenneth L. Marcus, the president of the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, which has joined with two law firms to bring the case against the ASA. “It’s about any association officer or director who is thinking about using their association as a tool to advance their own ideological agenda. This should send a signal that if association activists are not concerned that BDS resolutions are anti-Semitic and may be a violation of academic freedom they should certainly be concerned that they may violate corporations law.”
“People who join an academic association have a right to rely on the association’s representations about what its mission is,” Marcus said. “This is about the betrayal of an organization’s fundamental purpose.”
ASA responded to the lawsuit in a brief written statement on Wednesday. “We respect the concerns that the current and former members have expressed, the complaint is under review by our attorneys, and we are open to proposals addressing the complaint to be handled within the internal processes and procedures of the ASA, to include submission of a formal resolution to the organization,” the association said.
Radhika Sainath, a staff attorney for Palestine Legal, rejected the lawsuit against ASA as “meritless” and part of a larger strategy to intimidate advocates for Palestinian rights.
“The ASA’s academic boycott resolution is aimed at promoting academic freedom for Palestinian scholars and students and thus falls squarely within the educational purposes for which it was established,” Sainath said via email. “Plaintiffs’ theory that the ultra vires doctrine could limit the ASA’s First Amendment right to endorse the academic boycott is meritless and will likely be thrown out by the court.”
“Israel advocacy groups have previously threatened to sue the ASA, alleging national origin discrimination and anti-Semitism,” Sainath wrote, linking to the appendix of a joint Palestine Legal/Center for Constitutional Rights report on what the groups characterize as “the widespread and growing suppression” of advocacy for Palestinian human rights in the U.S. “Today’s lawsuit abandons these theories. As Palestine Legal and CCR documented in our report, meritless legal threats are a tactic used to chill speech supporting Palestinian rights. Such threats are being used to intimidate advocates for Palestinian rights and deflect the conversation away from Israeli human rights violations.”
Eugene Kontorovich, a professor at Northwestern University’s Pritzker School of Law who is advising the plaintiffs’ legal team in the case against ASA, argued that the First Amendment principle that’s at stake is not one of free speech but of freedom of association. “There is freedom of association in America, but part of that freedom is when people support associations with their money and their human capital they need to know what they’re getting,” he said.
“They can say anything they want,” Kontorovich said. “The only question is, can they conduct as an association activities that contradict their mission?”
The four American Studies professors and current or former ASA members who have filed suit against the ASA are Michael L. Barton, Simon Bronner and Charles D. Kupfer, all of Pennsylvania State University at Harrisburg, and Michael Rockland of Rutgers University. Bronner and Rockland are both honorary lifetime members of the association; Bronner is also an officer and editor of the ASA’s Encyclopedia of American Studies Online.
Read more by
Topics
College Pages
Inside Higher Ed Careers
Browse Faculty Jobs
Browse Administrative Jobs
Browse Executive Administration Jobs
You may also be interested in...
Today’s News from Inside Higher Ed
Inside Higher Ed’s Quick Takes
Popular Right Now
Removal of USC business school dean prompts outrage and questions
Essay about how white male students dominate discussions sets off debate at Dickinson and beyond
Proposal for payroll withholding sets off debate on student loan system
Advice for faculty members on how to teach students how to learn (opinion)
Publishers express concern about unintended consequences of Plan S
NYU social work school admits to institutional racism in wake of student email
Recommendations for an optimal conclusion to Hampshire College (opinion)
College students are still taking a knee against racism
A community college president's campaign against stigma about two-year institutions
Sign Up / Sign In
With your existing account from...
{* loginWidget *}With a traditional account...
{* #signInForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *} {* currentPassword *} {* /signInForm *}Newsletter enrollment
Existing account found
We have found an existing account for the email address.
Please sign in to update your newsletter preferences.
{* /signInForm *}Newsletter opt-out
Edit your newsletter preferences
Account Info
Sign In
Welcome back, {* welcomeName *}!
{* loginWidget *}Sign In
Welcome Back
Account Deactivated
Your account has been deactivated.
Account Reactivation Failed
Sorry, we could not verify that email address.
Email Verification Required
You must verify your email address before signing in. Check your email for your verification email, or enter your email address in the form below to resend the email.
{* #resendVerificationForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Almost Done
Please confirm the information below before signing in.
{* #socialRegistrationForm *} {* firstName *} {* lastName *} {* displayName *} {* emailAddress *} {* optInIHE *} {* optIn3rdParty *} {* agreeToTerms *}Almost Done
Please confirm the information below before signing in. Already have an account? Sign In.
{* #registrationForm *} {* firstName *} {* lastName *} {* displayName *} {* emailAddress *} {* newPassword *} {* newPasswordConfirm *} {* optInIHE *} {* optIn3rdParty *} {* agreeToTerms *}Thank You for Registering
We have sent a confirmation email to {* emailAddressData *}. Please check your email and click on the link to verify your email address.
Create New Password
We'll send you a link to create a new password.
{* #forgotPasswordForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Create New Password
We've sent an email with instructions to create a new password. Your existing password has not been changed.
Create New Password
This email address was registered with a social account. We've sent an email with instructions to create a new password, which can be used in addition to your linked social providers.
{| current_emailAddress |}
{| foundExistingAccountText |} {| current_emailAddress |}.
{| existing_displayName |} - {| existing_provider |} : {| existing_siteName |} {| existing_createdDate |}
{| existing_provider_emailAddress |}
Sign In to Complete Account Merge
Resend Verification Email
Sorry, we could not verify that email address. Enter your email below, and we'll send you another email.
{* #resendVerificationForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Change Password
Create New Password
We didn't recognize that password reset code. Enter your email below, and we'll send you another email.
{* #resetPasswordForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Create New Password
We've sent you an email with instructions to create a new password. Your existing password has not been changed.
Edit Your Account
Profile Photo
Linked Accounts
Link Your Accounts
This allows you to sign in to your account using that provider in the future.
Password
Deactivate Account
Change Password
Deactivate Your Account
Are you sure you want to deactivate your account? You will no longer have access to your profile.
{* deactivateAccountForm *} {* /deactivateAccountForm *}
Expand commentsHide comments — Join the conversation!