Can mediums tell if someone is alive or dead by looking at their photograph?
That question may sound like the premise of a second-rate television detective series or an episode of The X-Files rather than a topic for a serious scientific study.
However, a French neuroscientist who set out to discover whether clairvoyants are genuinely psychic has said that his experiment has shown that the idea of supernatural activity should not be entirely dismissed.
As part of his exploration of parapsychology, Arnaud Delorme, professor of neuroscience at Paul Sabatier University in Toulouse, asked 12 people from San Francisco who “claimed to be able to experience feelings of vitality from facial photographs alone” to look at about 400 portraits of different individuals.
The photographs, taken mostly from old American school yearbooks, were turned to black-and-white images to hide the eras in which they were taken (1939-41 and 1962-68), with test subjects asked to press a button to say whether they thought the individual in the picture was still living or not.
According to the results of the study, published in the journal Frontiers in Human Neuroscience in April, many of the participants “‘felt’ a difference between images of deceased and living individuals,” which was “compatible” with their claims of clairvoyant powers.
Delorme, who is also connected to the University of California, San Diego, said that his data should “warrant further investigation of that hypothesis” and also support “claims of individuals who report that some as yet unknown features of the face predict mortality."
However, Delorme’s efforts to probe the supernatural may have taken a knock after his paper, titled “Predictions of Mortality Based on Facial Characteristics,” was pulled from Frontiers over concerns that the “paper’s findings and assertions were not sufficiently matched by the level of verifiable evidence presented.”
It follows postpublication concerns about the paper, with critics pointing out that there was no control group involving people who did not claim to be psychic, reported the website Retraction Watch.
Indeed, the Californian mediums were able to guess correctly only in 53.8 percent of cases -- slightly better than chance, critics pointed out.
The inclusion of several photographs of U.S. politicians in the photo set may also have skewed the results, as participants may have unknowingly recognized them and known whether they were still alive, according to the blog Neurocritic.
Those criticisms have led the Switzerland-based journal to conclude that there were “serious issues concerning the scientific soundness and methodology” of the paper, Retraction Watch reported.
The site also pointed out that Delorme, a Zen meditator, gained funding for the project from the Bial Foundation, which aims to “foster the scientific study of the human being from both the physical and spiritual perspectives.” He is also affiliated with the Institute of Noetic Sciences, which focuses on topics including “intuition, distant and ‘energy’ healing … mind-matter interaction [and] transformative experiences,” it added.
Delorme told Times Higher Education that he believed the behavior of the editors of Frontiers violated rules regarding publication ethics because “no objective reasons were provided for the retraction” and he was also given no opportunity to appeal the decision.
In a statement published on the Institute for Noetic Sciences website, he called on fellow scientists to email the publisher to protest against the retraction, saying that “science thrives on healthy debate, not on censorship.”
“Whether or not our colleagues in the scientific community are inclined to entertain the subject matter of the article in question, all academic scholars should object to unethical retractions of peer-reviewed published research,” he added.
Read more by
You may also be interested in...
Today’s News from Inside Higher Ed
Inside Higher Ed’s Quick Takes
What Others Are Reading