German professors are more likely to respond to those seeking information on doctoral programs if they are educated in the U.S. than at more prestigious institutions in some Asian countries, study finds.
Academics need to ask themselves whether they discriminate against overseas scholars on the basis of their home country, according to a researcher who says he has found evidence of a “caste system” in global academe.
Professors in Germany were far more likely to respond to a request for doctoral supervision from U.S. university-based researchers than to those from Singapore and Vietnam, even if the Asian applicants’ universities were more highly ranked, an experiment found.
Nearly 400 sociology professors were sent identical applications, all with ethnic Chinese-sounding names, purporting to be from Yale University, Pennsylvania State University, the National University of Singapore or Vietnam National University, Hanoi.
Fifty-one percent of Yale candidates received a positive response, compared with 43.4 percent for Penn State, 30 percent for National University of Singapore (NUS) and 29 percent for Vietnam National University.
U.S.-based candidates were nearly three times more likely to be given extra information in their response, such as graduate school suggestions, and more than twice as likely to receive an enthusiastic response or to be addressed by their first name.
This is despite the fact that NUS does better than Penn State in many international rankings. Despite NUS’s “success as a university, it does not seem to have been able to shake off the label of a scientifically (semi-)peripheral Southeast Asian country (at least in the eyes of many German university professors),” concludes “Global inequality in the academic system: effects of national and university symbolic capital on international academic mobility,” published in Higher Education.
The study also revealed an Ivy League bias -- Penn State’s sociology department performs better than Yale’s in several rankings, but its fictional candidates were still less likely to receive a positive response.
The findings point to the existence of a “global academic caste system,” with the “U.S. or the U.K. at the top,” that has “significant consequences for how the international mobility of students and academics is channeled,” according to the paper.
The study is only “small and exploratory,” and similar experiments in other countries might yield different results, according to Daniel Drewski, a research associate at the Free University of Berlin and one of the authors.
Nonetheless, the results showed that academics paid more attention to “country or region” than rankings, Drewski said, although he added, “It’s also useful to pay less attention to universities’ rankings … The ideal would be to make decisions based on individual merit.”
“Overall, the emergence of this caste system is related to the distribution of economic power and historical legacy,” he said, which was something that academics could do little about.
Still, academics could reflect on their own biases when making such decisions, he said. The German professors surveyed in the research had made informal, personal decisions by email, which were more likely to be biased, he argued, because quick judgments were more likely to rely on a cursory look at someone’s home country and university.
Read more by
Topics
College Pages
Inside Higher Ed Careers
Browse Faculty Jobs
Browse Administrative Jobs
Browse Executive Administration Jobs
You may also be interested in...
Today’s News from Inside Higher Ed
Inside Higher Ed’s Quick Takes
Popular Right Now
Study documents economic gains from liberal arts education
NYU social work school admits to institutional racism in wake of student email
Judge says that U of Texas at Austin can't revoke former student's Ph.D. on its own, outside court o
The far-reaching effects of how campuses treat senior faculty of color (opinion)
How to improve student persistence and completion (essay)
Survey asks community college students to detail their challenges
How to adapt the German apprenticeship model to work best in the U.S.
A look at the data and arguments about Asian-Americans and admissions at elite colleges
Report predicts alternative credentials' sweeping impact on higher education
Hate crime hoaxes present burdens, lessons for college campuses
Sign Up / Sign In
With your existing account from...
{* loginWidget *}With a traditional account...
{* #signInForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *} {* currentPassword *} {* /signInForm *}Newsletter enrollment
Existing account found
We have found an existing account for the email address.
Please sign in to update your newsletter preferences.
{* /signInForm *}Newsletter opt-out
Edit your newsletter preferences
Account Info
Sign In
Welcome back, {* welcomeName *}!
{* loginWidget *}Sign In
Welcome Back
Account Deactivated
Your account has been deactivated.
Account Reactivation Failed
Sorry, we could not verify that email address.
Email Verification Required
You must verify your email address before signing in. Check your email for your verification email, or enter your email address in the form below to resend the email.
{* #resendVerificationForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Almost Done
Please confirm the information below before signing in.
{* #socialRegistrationForm *} {* firstName *} {* lastName *} {* displayName *} {* emailAddress *} {* optInIHE *} {* optIn3rdParty *} {* agreeToTerms *}Almost Done
Please confirm the information below before signing in. Already have an account? Sign In.
{* #registrationForm *} {* firstName *} {* lastName *} {* displayName *} {* emailAddress *} {* newPassword *} {* newPasswordConfirm *} {* optInIHE *} {* optIn3rdParty *} {* agreeToTerms *}Thank You for Registering
We have sent a confirmation email to {* emailAddressData *}. Please check your email and click on the link to verify your email address.
Create New Password
We'll send you a link to create a new password.
{* #forgotPasswordForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Create New Password
We've sent an email with instructions to create a new password. Your existing password has not been changed.
Create New Password
This email address was registered with a social account. We've sent an email with instructions to create a new password, which can be used in addition to your linked social providers.
{| current_emailAddress |}
{| foundExistingAccountText |} {| current_emailAddress |}.
{| existing_displayName |} - {| existing_provider |} : {| existing_siteName |} {| existing_createdDate |}
{| existing_provider_emailAddress |}
Sign In to Complete Account Merge
Resend Verification Email
Sorry, we could not verify that email address. Enter your email below, and we'll send you another email.
{* #resendVerificationForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Change Password
Create New Password
We didn't recognize that password reset code. Enter your email below, and we'll send you another email.
{* #resetPasswordForm *} {* signInEmailAddress *}Create New Password
We've sent you an email with instructions to create a new password. Your existing password has not been changed.
Edit Your Account
Profile Photo
Linked Accounts
Link Your Accounts
This allows you to sign in to your account using that provider in the future.
Password
Deactivate Account
Change Password
Deactivate Your Account
Are you sure you want to deactivate your account? You will no longer have access to your profile.
{* deactivateAccountForm *} {* /deactivateAccountForm *}
Expand commentsHide comments — Join the conversation!