A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit claiming that the National Collegiate Athletic Association and the Pac-12 Conference infringed on labor laws and thus owed money to a former Division I football player.
The suit, filed by ex-University of Southern California football player Lamar Dawson, represents the continued legal battle to redefine college athletes as employees and secure them compensation.
California Judge Richard Seeborg threw out Dawson’s case Tuesday, writing that the U.S. Department of Labor has not historically considered athletes employees under the Fair Labor Standards Act, which Dawson had alleged the NCAA and Pac-12 violated, along with the California labor code.
Seeborg wrote in his order that he was persuaded by a similar case in the Seventh U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which decided “the long tradition of amateurism in college sports, by definition, shows that student athletes -- like all amateur athletes -- participate in their sports for reasons wholly unrelated to immediate compensation.”
Multiple courts have found that student athletes are not employees, Seeborg wrote.
Dawson argued that the Seventh Circuit case concerned University of Pennsylvania track and field athletes, who were not bringing in the same “massive revenues” as a Division I football team. He likened his team and others that generate revenue for institutions to a work-study program.
But Seeborg, too, rejected this, noting that the federal labor law does not distinguish between sports that rake in money for an institution and those that do not.
“There is a difference between work-study programs, which exist for the benefit of the school, and football programs, which exist for the benefit of students and, in some limited circumstances, also benefit the school,” Seeborg wrote.
Opinions on Inside Higher Ed
Inside Higher Ed’s Blog U
Inside Higher Ed Careers
Hiring? Post A Job Today!
Browse Faculty Jobs
Browse Administrative Jobs
Browse Executive Administration Jobs
College Pages
Popular Right Now
Chapman professor who spoke at Jan. 6 pro-Trump rally retires
Education Department releases billions in aid to colleges
Grand Canyon sues U.S. Education Department for rejecting its conversion to nonprofit status
10 strategies to support students and help them learn during the coronavirus crisis (opinion)
First faculty and staff outside health-care fields become eligible for COVID vaccines, but prioritiz
Live Updates: Latest News on Coronavirus and Higher Education
CDC Compares COVID-19 Rates in Counties With In-Person and Remote Classes
Long-term online learning in pandemic may impact students' well-being
Smart, Succinct and Agile: Strategic Planning in an Age of Uncertainty | A Special Report from Insid
Expand commentsHide comments