Women are 2.5 times less likely than men to ask questions in departmental academic seminars, based on a new study of 250 talks at 35 institutions in 10 countries. The study also considered survey responses from some 600 academics across fields in 20 countries. The surveys indicate that male and female respondents sometimes don’t ask questions when they want to ask them. But, unlike men, women said they refrained due to internal versus external factors, such as “not feeling clever enough” or “couldn't work up the nerve.”
In the observational study, women tended to ask more questions when more questions were asked: When 15 questions were asked in all, beyond the median of six, there was 8 percent increase in the proportion of questions asked by women. When the first question in a seminar was asked by a man, the proportion of subsequent questions asked by women decreased by 6 percent, according to the study.
"While calling on people in the order that they raise their hands may seem fair, it may inadvertently result in fewer women asking questions because they might need more time to formulate questions and work up the nerve," co-author Alyssa Croft, an assistant professor of psychology at the University of Arizona, said in a statement. Among other possible interventions, the study recommends that departments take a small break between talks and question-and-answer periods so that women have time to formulate their questions. “Women’s Visibility in Academic Seminars: Women Ask Fewer Questions than Men” was published in PLOS One.
Opinions on Inside Higher Ed
Inside Higher Ed’s Blog U
Trending Stories
- Tulane admitted two-thirds of its class early this year
- 8 Ways to Improve Your Online Course | Higher Ed Gamma
- Philosophers should not be sanctioned for their positions on sex and gender (opinion)
- Authors discuss book on "becoming great universities"
- Why asking students their preferred pronoun is not a good idea (opinion)
Most Shared Stories
- Tulane admitted two-thirds of its class early this year | Inside Higher Ed
- Seven professor actions that contribute to student well-being (infographic)
- University could fire writing professor over "deviant pornography"
- Adopt 'crip time' to make higher ed more inclusive (opinion) | Inside Higher Ed
- Polarizing hire at Morehouse College sparks controversy
Expand commentsHide comments